Five question marks after Sundowns’ shock CAF Champions League elimination

Mamelodi Sundowns’ shock elimination from the CAF Champions League has raised serious questions about the defending champions, who were knocked out by Angola’s Wiliete SC on the away-goals rule after a 1-1 aggregate draw. Here are five issues Masandawana must confront.

1. Did over-confidence cost Sundowns?

Having competed in international tournaments, including the FIFA Club World Cup and the FIFA Africa-Asian-Pacific Cup, Sundowns have gained valuable global experience. But did their success breed complacency? Against Wiliete, the Brazilians were favourites, yet failed to turn their dominance into qualification. Did they underestimate their opponents?

2. Have too many matches taken their toll?

Sundowns have juggled domestic and international commitments, including the MTN8 and the FIFA Africa-Asian-Pacific Cup. While their trophy-winning ambitions demand a packed schedule, has the workload affected their sharpness, freshness and concentration in crucial matches?

3. Is the lack of a settled line-up hurting the team?

The absence of key players, including Teboho Mokoena, Grant Kekana, Keanu Cupido and Khuliso Mudau, has disrupted continuity. Sundowns’ strength has traditionally been their depth, but frequent changes can affect defensive understanding and midfield balance. Can they maintain their identity without a consistent starting eleven?

4. Is Brayan León delivering in the biggest games?

Signed to strengthen Sundowns’ attack, Colombian striker Brayan León came under scrutiny after missing important chances against Wiliete. He has scored only three goals in the 2026/27 season, according to available match statistics. Can he translate his scoring ability into decisive performances on the continental stage? The season is still young, but expectations are high.

5. Are Sundowns too dependent on Teboho Mokoena?

Mokoena brings personality, courage and authority to Sundowns’ midfield. When the Bafana Bafana international is unavailable, the team can appear to lack the same control and competitive edge. Is his influence so significant that Sundowns struggle to replace him, or must other midfielders take greater responsibility?

The elimination is more than a disappointing result. It is a warning that Sundowns must turn their resources and reputation into consistent performances when the pressure is highest.