Apex Scores Lite Apex Scores Lite flag
back Kembali
Paul Scholes names Man Utd managerial candidate ‘streets ahead’ of the rest
Paul Scholes has a preferred candidate for Manchester United manager (Picture: The Good, The Bad and The Football)

Paul Scholes says there is one manager ‘streets ahead’ of other candidates when it comes to replacing Michael Carrick at Manchester United.

Carrick remains in charge of the Red Devils, but after a nightmare start to the season he is not expected to last much longer in the job.

A 3-0 defeat to Bournemouth at Old Trafford on Sunday made it eight matches without a win and one victory in eight Premier League outings.

Performances and results have been awful, while there has also been off-field controversy, with Lisandro Martinez speaking out against the club’s hierarchy and club captain Bruno Fernandes criticising Carrick and his coaching staff.

It is hard to see Carrick turning things around and if a change does come then Scholes feels former Chelsea, Juventus, Napoli and Tottenham boss Antonio Conte is the man for the job.

Presented with three names: Conte, Eddie Howe and Julian Naglesmann, Scholes says there is clearly a right choice.

However, he recognises the volatile nature of the Italian and questions if he would even want to come to Old Trafford.

Mandatory Credit: Photo by Nicola Ianuale/Shutterstock (16896617u) Antonio Conte head coach of SSC Napoli greets the supporters at the end the Serie A match between SSC Napoli and Udinese Calcio at Diego Armando Maradona Stadium in Naples, Italy on May 24, 2026. SSC Napoli v Udinese Calcio, Italian Serie A 2025-26 , 24 May 2026, Stadio Diego Armando Maradona, Campania, Italy - 24 May 2026
Antonio Conte is available after leaving Napoli in May (Picture: Shutterstock)

Speaking on The Good, The Bad and The Football, Scholes said: ‘You’d have to pick a manager who you think will get us back to being a competitive team for the Premier League. Out of them three, Antonio Conte’s the man, but he comes with a big f***ing massive warning.

‘He’s made noises that he wants to come and I’m pretty sure the club would have spoke to all three of them.

Ask Metro

‘I can’t understand why he’d want this job because I don’t think the team’s good enough for him, personally.’

The Red Devils legend suggested another candidate in Aston Villa manager Unai Emery, but still plumped for Conte as his first choice.

‘Is the answer staring us right in the face in Unai Emery?’ Scholes asked. ‘He’s won the Europa League with Aston Villa, do you know what an achievement that is?

SC Freiburg v Aston Villa FC - UEFA Europa League Final 2026
Unai Emery is doing a superb job as Aston Villa manager (Picture: Getty Images)

‘He gets a new team every single year because they have to sell their best players. and he keeps producing, keeps producing.

‘Is everyone put off by his Arsenal and PSG days? Probably, because it’s a big club. But it might be staring us in the face. He’d have to take United over Villa, I think he would.

‘I think Conte’s the best one around. When I’m talking best in class and you talk them four, I think Antonio Conte’s miles ahead of all of them.

‘You think Juventus, he went to Napoli and goes and wins the league with them.’

Soccer Football - Serie A - Napoli v Cagliari - Stadio Diego Armando Maradona, Naples, Italy - May 23, 2025 Napoli coach Antonio Conte is thrown in the air by his players as they celebrates winning Serie A REUTERS/Matteo Ciambelli TPX IMAGES OF THE DAY
Conte has won Serie A with Juventus, Inter and Napoli and the Premier League with Chelsea (Picture: REUTERS)

Conte has taken charge of nine clubs in his managerial career and his longest stint at any was three seasons as Juventus boss from 2011-14. Nowhere else has he stayed longer than two campaigns.

Scholes accepts that may well happen at Old Trafford as well, but reckons that if he could quickly fire the club back into contention and then leave, it would still be a successful stint in charge.

‘He’s volatile, I know he’s volatile and might be a bit of a madman, but when you talk about successful managers at top clubs he’s streets ahead,’ said Scholes.

‘I don’t care if it’s short term. I don’t care if he’s there 18 months and he gets us challenging for the league, that would be a success.

‘The more and more I think about it, Conte needs to come in and start banging some heads together.’

Another former Manchester United star, who played under Conte at Inter Milan, has warned of the potential ‘disaster’ of appointing the Italian.

MADRID, SPAIN - OCTOBER 13: Ashley Young gives an interview prior to the UEFA Champions League 2026/27 League Phase MD2 match between Atletico de Madrid and Manchester United at Estadio Metropolitano on October 13, 2026 in Madrid, Spain. (Photo by Maciej Rogowski/Eurasia Sport Images/Getty Images)
Ashley Young had words of warning over Antonio Conte (Picture: Getty Images)

Ashley Young told Overlap Daily: ‘I’ve worked underneath him at Inter. He’s crazy by the way, crazy. A lot of talk has been about Man United’s running stats. If they’re not going to run and Antonio Conte goes in there, it’s going to be a disaster I think.

‘The training sessions were a lot of 11 vs 11, at times a little bit boring. Meetings were long. When I say long, I’m talking, if we lost a game, we could go in for the meeting and he’d stop literally everything and you could be in there for three or four hours.

‘I think that’s one of the reasons why he doesn’t last long at places because it’s not just the players he tries to test mentally, but the board as well, and the owners. I think that people get annoyed with him and think “it’s time for you to go”.’

You may like

Arsenal trio deserve no better than 29th, 21st and 15th in Ballon d’Or as every player’s ranking ...

football365.com 3 jam yang lalu

Manchester United officially appoint former Chelsea coach

centredevils.co.uk 6 jam yang lalu

Bruno Fernandes sends brutal 'no longer care' message to Man Utd amid Michael Carrick row

The Daily Star 13 jam yang lalu

Eddie Howe reaches decision on becoming new Man Utd manager amid career ‘break’

football365.com 14 jam yang lalu

After Spurs nightmare, one Chelsea player starting vs Liverpool is now a no-brainer

thechelseachronicle.com 1 jam yang lalu

Steven Gerrard draws parallels between Man Utd demise and Liverpool — 'We've lived it'

liverpool.com 2 jam yang lalu

Harry Kane wins football’s Ballon d’Or, England’s first winner in 25 years

nzherald.co.nz 19 menit yang lalu

Ex-Leicester City star Jamie Vardy caught up in Burnley managerial change after 14 games

leicestermercury.co.uk 12 jam yang lalu

Unai Emery will leave Aston Villa for Manchester United

centredevils.co.uk 12 jam yang lalu

Roy Keane touted for shock Man Utd manager appointment by his former striker

teamtalk.com 9 jam yang lalu