Apex Scores Lite Apex Scores Lite flag
back Retour
Michael Carrick replacement named immediately after Man Utd crisis meeting

BIG DEBATE: Our Express Sport writers pick the next Manchester United manager, with Michael Carrick on the verge of being sacked.

Manchester United v Aston Villa FC - Premier League 2026/27
Michael Carrick is close to being sacked by Manchester United. (Image: Getty)

Manchester United are set to sack Michael Carrick this week and work has already begun on the Englishman's replacement. A dire 2026/27 campaign has left the Red Devils in the Premier League relegation zone over the November international break, with INEOS chiefs set to recommend to Sir Jim Ratcliffe that Carrick lose his job.

CEO Omar Berrada and director of football Jason Wilcox have led a review into the situation, following crisis meetings in recent weeks, and will next be tasked with finding a new head coach.

Mauricio Pochettino and Eddie Howe have emerged as the early frontrunners, while free agents Julian Nagelsmann and Antonio Conte are in contention too.

Here, Express Sport has given our verdict on who we think should be named the next United boss...

Manchester United need a manager with a unique skill set.

The ideal candidate needs to have experience competing with a squad punching above its weight, they need to have experience working in a chaotic environment which could prove too much for most other bosses, and they need to have experience bringing through youth if they don’t want to incur the wrath of the Class of 92 media ecosystem.

Pochettino’s ability to produce results in what sounded like a nightmare situation at Chelsea ought to work in his favour for what also feels like a near-impossible role at United.

The biggest argument against them appointing him now is that they should really have done it years ago.

Amos Murphy: Eddie Howe

The goalposts have shifted for United now. Gone are the days of them needing a manager to take them back to the top, the Red Devils need stability more than anything else. Howe might be Mr Sensible, but he’s the sort of manager who can bring back a sense of calm, and in truth, normality.

Conte is a car crash waiting to happen; Nagelsmann is a risk, Pochettino might work, but it carries its own set of problems. You know what you’re getting with Howe, and it’s no thrills, but what if that is exactly what United need?

United States v Canada - International Friendly
Mauricio Pochettino is becoming a leading contender to take over. (Image: Getty)

Archie Griggs: Mauricio Pochettino

I honestly don't think it matters who comes in at United, because the club is rotten from the top down and things will only meaningfully improve when the Glazer family and INEOS are no longer in control.

However, if they decide to sack Carrick, they'll have to appoint somebody, so why not give Pochettino a go?

United's top brass clearly weren't convinced by the likes of Eddie Howe and Julian Nagelsmann when they considered a managerial change last month.

There would be little point in recruiting a head coach who would lack the confidence of his superiors before a ball has even been kicked.

That leaves Pochettino as the best option, although questions remain given his underwhelming spell in charge of Chelsea a few years back.

Jack McEachen: Mauricio Pochettino

The options available aren't what Manchester United had hoped for, as highlighted by their reluctance to sack Carrick last month.

But Pochettino does tick the most boxes.

He's managed egos, delivered consistently in the Premier League and been effusive in the face of media speculation.

The Argentine has struggled to hit the heights of his days at Tottenham, but it's been some time since Howe, Conte or Nagelsmann were on top either.

Pochettino's high-press system might be exactly what this group of stagnating United players need. A jolt of lightning could inspire them back to the team that earned so much praise under Carrick only a few months ago.

He will need to be backed in January, however.

EXPRESS SPORT ON FB! Get all the best sports news and much more on our Facebook page

Stay up-to-date with the latest Man Utd news

Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. Read our Privacy Policy

You may like

Next Man Utd manager favourite emerges with two current Premier League bosses on shortlist

The Daily Star il y a 2 heures

Sir Alex Ferguson has already told Man Utd how he feels about Mauricio Pochettino becoming manager

sportbible.com il y a 2 heures

Man Utd fans identify the first thing Sir Alex Ferguson would change

unitedinfocus.com il y a 2 heures

'I met genius Sir Alex Ferguson for lunch and we argued over who would pay. I came so close, I wa...

fourfourtwo.com il y a 2 heures

Arsenal legend says Gunners ‘can’t win Champions League’ as two-word claim made

The Daily Star il y a 1 heure

What Michael Owen noticed about Man Utd fans after Villa draw

unitedinfocus.com il y a 4 heures

Ruben Amorim rejects Brighton offer

centredevils.co.uk il y a 2 heures

Asking fans the question, are Newcastle United in a relegation fight this 2026-27 season? Vote now

themag.co.uk il y a 59 minutes

Declan Rice responds to claims he’s performative on camera

arsenalinsider.com il y a 1 heure