Apex Scores Lite Apex Scores Lite flag
back Back
Ex-Premier League Referee Reveals If Liverpool Star Should Have Been Sent Off Vs Arsenal
REUTERS/Phil Noble

Lee is a Senior Editor and Content Strategist at GiveMeSport with more than 20 years' experience in the media industry, previously working on the Mirror and football.london.
Lee graduated from Southampton Solent University in 2005 with a journalism degree before starting out as a news reporter on his loacl paper in Kent.
He has worked his way up from news reporter to sports reporter and then editor through excellent writing, great communication and an effective team leadership style.

Sign in to your GiveMeSport account

Arsenal picked up all three points in the big game against Liverpool at Anfield on Sunday to move to the top of the Premier League table.

Kai Havertz scored the only goal of the game, but there were plenty of talking points beyond that solitary goal to keep fans and pundits alike occupied.

Five minutes after the German put the Gunners in front, Liverpool were denied a penalty when Alexander Isak had his shirt pulled in the box, stopping him from being able to connect with Bradley Barcola's centre. Referee Andy Madley did not see it and VAR refused to overrule the decision, causing plenty of anger in the Sky Sports studio and on social media.

Before either of those two incidents, however, there were plenty of suggestions that young Liverpool midfielder Trey Nyoni should have been sent off.

As early as the first minute, Nyoni appeared to put his studs down the back of Martin Odegaard's leg, connecting with his Achilles.

Just 24 hours earlier, Jean-Philippe Mateta had been sent off for a similar offence when sliding in on Tottenham captain Micky van de Ven. However, no card was brandished and VAR did not get involved either, causing plenty of consternation on social media.

Former Premier League referee Graham Barber exclusively told GIVEMESPORT that the incident was different to that of Mateta and that the right call was probably made.

True or False: 2025/26 EPL True or False

He said: "I think the sending off when we talk about the other one was about the intensity and ferociousness of the challenge.

"I think with this one it was mis-timed. I don't think he meant to hurt the player, but the question you raise is, and we've had this conversation before, do you get consistency from match to match? And sadly you don't, and then we start comparing game incidents in other games.

"It's very difficult to do that and here I thought it was a careless challenge, I didn't think it was reckless."

Later on in the match there was an incident involving Alexis Mac Allister and Noni Madueke, with VAR having to check to see if the Arsenal man had headbutted the Liverpool midfielder, who ended up on the deck.

The incident was checked and cleared by VAR Stuart Attwell and Barber decided to go in on Mac Allister's behaviour.

He added: "I think the only talking point about that is the despicable behaviour of Mac Allister. Not only was it an attempt to get a player sent off who shouldn't be sent off, but then also, instigated a melee of players who potentially wouldn't have got involved in something because of his behaviour.

"Why professional footballers do that I have no idea, so forget the Madueke thing, I just can't understand why a professional footballer would behave like that."

You may like

Man Utd 'Will Pull The Trigger On Carrick' After Chelsea Loss As Guardiola Claim Made

givemesport.com 2 days ago

Ex-PGMOL Chief Blasts Liverpool vs Arsenal Referee For One Massive Error He Made

givemesport.com 1 day ago

The 15 players with most Premier League red cards ever - top three are no shock

express.co.uk 1 day ago

Lionel Messi benefits from MLS rule that doesn't exist in any other league

sportbible.com 1 day ago

Ex-Premier League Referee Casts Strong VAR Verdict After Alexander Isak Penalty Call

givemesport.com 1 day ago

Manchester United given 'perfect' Lisandro Martinez red card verdict as appeal proposed

standard.co.uk 15 hours ago

'Lucky': Arsenal get double referee verdict over Noni Madueke and Jurrien Timber incidents

standard.co.uk 16 hours ago

Liverpool fans fume as tunnel footage of Gabriel and referee comes to light

mirror.co.uk 17 hours ago

Gabriel and Mac Allister's cheating is not just embarrassing, it's malevolent and wicked... playe...

dailymail.com 1 day ago

Gary Neville says Trey Nyoni is 'very lucky boy' after two incidents vs Arsenal

liverpool.com 1 day ago