Some Manchester United players have reportedly expressed a preference for Aston Villa manager Unai Emery over Mauricio Pochettino as a potential replacement for Michael Carrick at Old Trafford.

According to a report by talkSPORT on Wednesday, November 11, 2026, the Manchester United dressing room is divided over the manager the club should consider appointing if the decision is made to relieve Carrick of his duties.

The report, which cited information from talkSPORT journalist Alex Crook, indicated that while Pochettino has emerged as a leading contender, some members of the squad would rather see Emery take charge of the team.

Pochettino, who currently manages the United States national team, is attracting attention because of his previous experience in English football. The former Tottenham Hotspur and Chelsea manager has also been linked with Manchester United on previous occasions.

However, some players reportedly believe Emery would be a suitable choice because of the progress he has achieved at Aston Villa since taking charge of the club.

The Spanish tactician has earned recognition for transforming Villa into competitive contenders for European qualification and establishing the team among the Premier League's ambitious sides.

Manchester United have also been linked with Emery in recent weeks. TEAMtalk reported on November 2 that the club held the former Arsenal manager in high regard, although convincing him to leave Aston Villa could prove difficult.

Meanwhile, uncertainty surrounding Carrick's position has continued to grow following United's disappointing results. Their recent 4-4 draw against Aston Villa reportedly intensified concerns about the team's performances and overall direction.

The situation has also placed senior club officials, including Sir Jim Ratcliffe, under pressure to consider possible changes to the managerial position.

Despite the reported interest in Emery and Pochettino, Manchester United have not confirmed any appointment plans. There is also no confirmation that the club has formally approached the Aston Villa manager about leaving his current position.