Apex Scores Lite Apex Scores Lite flag
back Back
Man City Fans Tear ‘Phenomenally Poor’ Duo to Shreds After Aston Villa Loss
Reuters/Lee Smith

Oct 24, 2026, 2:22 PM GMT+1

Robin Mumford is a journalist for GiveMeSport, covering mainly Champions League and Premier League football.

He joined in April 2024, having previously worked at VAVEL as Deputy Editor-in-Chief, where he produced a variety of content, including pieces from press conferences and games. He also won an award for his role as lead editor for the Women's Football section of the online newspaper.

Covering football all across Europe, he has worked at stadiums such as Anfield, Old Trafford, and Dortmund's Signal Iduna Park, as well as having reported at both the 2023 men's and women's Champions League finals in Eindhoven and Istanbul.

He is infatuated with every aspect of football, but likes other sports as well, being an avid coffee-desperate Buffalo Bills supporter from across the pond and a darts' newbie.

Sign in to your GiveMeSport account

While Manchester City put in an unusually lukewarm performance in a 2-1 loss away to Aston Villa on Saturday afternoon, there have been two star players in particular who have felt the heat following their first Premier League defeat of the season.

Enzo Maresca's side remain top of the table as things stand, and will stay there beyond this weekend should Arsenal fail to win their game-in-hand by more than four clear goals.

But there were obvious warning signs for Enzo Maresca that his side can be got at, especially when their opposition is aggressive, and their fans hostile.

Nicolas Jackson scored either side of an Erling Haaland equaliser, and that proved enough for the Villains to extend their impressive run against the Cityzens, who have now won four of the last six meetings between the two sides.

Man City Duo Looked Out of their Depth at Hostile Villa Park

Aston Villa
REUTERS/Tony O Brien

It's not often that a Man City side looks out of place, outnumbered in midfield, and unable to keep up with their opponents in an intense atmosphere. Cool, calm, collected is usually personified by the Cityzens, but their fans have been left fearing two of their star players didn't match that description at all in Saturday's lunchtime kick-off.

The travelling supporters have called out both Marc Guehi, who was at fault for an error leading to Nicolas Jackson's opener, and £125 million summer signing Enzo Fernandez for their 'phenomenally poor' displays in the Midlands. Another X user commented:

"Marc Guehi and Enzo Fernandez will be the end of this club."

A third added that both players looked 'lost' in the high-octane clash, as a fourth remarked: "The Enzo Fernandez signing ruined the whole Man City project post-Pep [Guardiola]."

Elsewhere, a sixth continued: "Guehi is all over the place this season, for City and England. Madness," a seventh claimed that "Nothing about Guehi screams world-class," as a ninth concluded: "Serious conversations need to be had about Fernandez and Guehi."

Man City Finally Give Up Ground in Premier League Title Race

Mikel Arteta (Arsenal)

With Arsenal unbeaten in their previous four matches across all competitions - the latest result of which saw them hold Bayern Munich to a 2-2 draw in the Champions League - the Gunners will be hoping to capitalise on the first time their long-time adversaries have dropped points in the Premier League this season.

A clash at home to Everton offers the perfect platform for Mikel Arteta and co. to move level on points at the top of the table. But with a goal difference four worse-off than their rivals, it still looks unlikely that they can finish the weekend as outright table-toppers.

Fees correct prior to summer 2026

All 10 found — excellent!

Perhaps the best thing to come out of City's failure to win at Villa Park from an Arsenal perspective is that they looked rattled at times, somewhat flustered by the hostile reception they were getting from the home support.

They may have rose to the occasion at Anfield, but two weeks later painted a different picture, and that pressure will only worsen as any punishment plans keep getting pushed back.

You may like

Eberechi Eze reaches decision on leaving Arsenal after demotion confirmed

teamtalk.com 6 hours ago

Man City charges LIVE: Three punishments facing club as Kyle Walker forced to backpedal

mirror.co.uk 1 day ago

Man City charges LIVE: Premier League face 'worst case scenario' after 'surprise' decision claim

mirror.co.uk 9 hours ago

Cole Palmer Debuts Bold New Haircut Ahead of Chelsea’s London Derby Against Tottenham

yen.com.gh 3 hours ago

Why do Man City fans bring inflatable bananas to stadiums?

standard.co.uk 8 hours ago

Mikel Arteta Urged to Replace 'Liability' Despite Premier League Win vs Everton

givemesport.com 35 minutes ago

Man City ready to sign Chelsea star in January in world record transfer – Exclusive

teamtalk.com 8 hours ago

Kai Rooney stuns fans as they call for Man Utd promotion after win over Liverpool U18s

mirror.co.uk 34 minutes ago

Man City facing four different punishments as Premier League clubs launch protests

express.co.uk 1 day ago

Arsenal capitalise on Man City slip-up but Mikel Arteta still left with concern

mirror.co.uk 34 minutes ago