here was a time when the author, John Dewhirst, was a familiar presence on the old Kop at Valley Parade, selling copies of The City Gent, the groundbreaking fanzine he co-founded in 1984. That was a very different Bradford City from the club we know today. There was no Premier League, no Sky Sports, no social media, and certainly no expectation that the club’s history would one day be examined in such detail. Valley Parade was a primitive ground by modern standards, with an uncovered Kop, a low covered stand on the Midland Road side, a ‘scratching shed’, and an ancient wooden stand that tragically burned down in 1985.

Dewhirst has been documenting Bradford’s sporting story ever since. A prolific writer, historian and photographer, he brings four decades of firsthand observation and research to The Bantams of Valley Parade, his comprehensive account of the club’s 123-year history. Having witnessed the promotions, the heartbreaks, the fire disaster, the Premier League adventure and the perilous descents into the lower divisions from the terraces, he brings a distinctive perspective to the club’s fortunes. The result is an incisive, illuminating and deeply-informed account that is also a pleasure to read.

Too often, club histories become weary, season-by-season parades of statistics, match reports and forgotten line-ups. Such exhaustive ledgers tell the reader precisely what happened while failing to explain why. Dewhirst avoids that trap. Rather than simply chronicling events, he offers a brisk, analytical narrative focused on the turning points, underlying forces and pivotal personalities that have shaped Bradford City from its inception to the present day.

The club’s origins remain extraordinary. In 1903, Manningham FC famously abandoned rugby to establish an association football club, retaining its iconic claret-and-amber colours and the Valley Parade ground. Seeking to establish a stronger presence in West Yorkshire, the Football League admitted the newly formed club to Division Two before it had played a competitive match. Within eight years, City had reached the top flight and won the FA Cup in 1911.

Yet Dewhirst does more than celebrate those early triumphs. He explores why they proved so difficult to sustain, tracing some of the roots of future instability to the club’s formative years. The transition from rugby left a legacy of cumbersome committee governance, with team selection controlled by a committee rather than a single manager, alongside persistent financial difficulties. Following relegation from the top flight in 1922, City entered a prolonged decline, eventually becoming trapped in the regionalised Third Division (North). Dewhirst’s treatment of this period is particularly revealing. He explains how a 24-club division, with shared gate receipts and just one promotion place, severely restricted City’s prospects despite its comparatively strong attendances.

Equally compelling is his examination of Bradford’s divided footballing loyalties. Dewhirst explores how competition between City and Bradford (Park Avenue) for local support and resources hindered both clubs. Avenue were eventually voted out of the Football League, and his account shows how closely intertwined the fortunes of the two sides had been, with neither finding it easy to establish a lasting advantage in the same city.

When he turns to the modern eras that many supporters remember firsthand, Dewhirst’s assessments of the club’s chairmen and owners are among the book’s strongest passages. Bob Martin, who notoriously sought to change the club’s colours, nickname and even its name to Bradford Metro FC, is presented in revealing detail. More significantly, Dewhirst offers a measured examination of the Geoffrey Richmond years, balancing Richmond’s transformative ambition against the financial collapse that followed relegation from the Premier League. Edin Rahic receives equally searching treatment, with Dewhirst looking beyond the emotion and folklore of the terraces to assess the consequences of ownership decisions.

The subsequent arrival of German businessman Stefan Rupp, initially in partnership with Rahic, marked the beginning of the most recent chapter in the club’s history. Since Rahic’s departure in 2018, City has enjoyed a degree of financial security that was largely absent in previous decades. Earlier periods of recovery were repeatedly interrupted by financial crises and acute cash-flow pressures, often returning within just a few years. Under Rupp, the club has developed a more professional off-field operation, with strengthened commercial and recruitment capabilities, greater provision for youth development and a sustained commitment to community engagement. These changes have helped reinforce the relationship between the club and the city it represents.

For Dewhirst, the significance of this development becomes clearer when viewed against the club’s longer history. Success at Valley Parade has repeatedly depended on individuals prepared to overcome circumstances that seemed to work against them. From legendary names like O’Rourke and Paton, Heginbotham, Cherry, Richmond, Parkinson, we see how successive figures have achieved periods of revival, only for their progress eventually to be undermined by the club’s underlying weaknesses. Restricted finances, limited strength in depth and the considerable cost of maintaining Valley Parade have repeatedly made sustained success difficult. Even managers with considerable ability, including Jack Peart in the 1930s and David Steele, Chris Kamara and Paul Jewell, in the post-war years, have struggled to make a lasting impact in such conditions.

Richmond’s tenure provides the starkest illustration of the risks involved in trying to overcome these limitations through financial leverage. His ambition took City to the Premier League, but the financial commitments made in pursuit of that achievement magnified the consequences of relegation. Rahic’s tenure exposed a different problem: the damage that individual decision-making can inflict when it is not matched by the experience and judgement needed to run a football club effectively.

Rupp’s ownership, by contrast, has helped address some of the structural weaknesses that repeatedly undermined his predecessors. His investment has provided a more secure financial base, while the development of the club’s commercial, recruitment and youth operations has strengthened its capacity to plan for the future. The discounted ticketing strategy introduced in 2007 has also played an important part in rebuilding the support base, underlining the value of maintaining a strong connection with the local community.

Against this background, Graham Alexander’s recent success in managing City to promotion in 2025 seems to represent more than another isolated revival. Previous recoveries often rested on exceptional individuals temporarily overcoming deep-rooted disadvantages. The more encouraging prospect under Rupp is that improved financial stability and a more developed organisational structure may allow sporting success to endure. Whether that promise can be fulfilled remains to be seen, but the foundations are more secure than they have been during many earlier periods in the club’s history.

Running through the book is a compelling central argument: Bradford City’s fortunes have rarely followed a straightforward path of steady growth. Instead, progress has depended on the interaction between individual ambition and the structural conditions in which the club operates. From the Cup triumph of 1911 and the tragedy of the 1985 fire to the Premier League adventure and the remarkable League Cup run that culminated in the 2013 Wembley final, Dewhirst captures the resilience and unpretentious underdog spirit that have long defined the Bantams. His account also suggests that the club’s future may depend less on finding another individual capable of defying the odds than on ensuring that the conditions for success are finally in place.

At 160 pages, The Bantams of Valley Parade is remarkably concise, making every word count without sacrificing analytical depth. Dewhirst’s decades spent among supporters, writing about the club and documenting its history as events unfolded lend the narrative an authenticity that very few other writers could have achieved.

This is not a book designed to compete with exhaustive statistical references or detailed accounts of individual matches. For anyone seeking to understand the historical forces, ownership struggles and enduring spirit that have shaped Bradford City AFC, Dewhirst has produced an essential and deeply-satisfying volume. It does more than recount what happened to Bradford City. Crucially, it helps explain why.

Sadly, there’s no mention of my personal hero, Mitchell Downie, the bravest keeper I ever saw, but then it’s not that kind of a book. A hagiography it is not, but a gritty and objective appraisal.

The shortened address for this article is: newspub.uk/121gz