Apex Scores Lite Apex Scores Lite flag
back Back
Former Chelsea and Sunderland stars disagree over Cole Palmer penalty decision
Cole Palmer of Chelsea reacts during the Premier League 2026/27 match between Sunderland and Chelsea FC at Stadium of Light
Photo by Robbie Jay Barratt – AMA/Getty Images

Chelsea were visibly frustrated with Jarred Gillett’s refereeing during their 1-0 defeat to Sunderland. The Blues felt several decisions went against them at the Stadium of Light on Sunday afternoon.

The two biggest incidents came inside the penalty area, with Brian Brobbey winning a spot-kick after going down under minimal contact from Levi Colwill. Meanwhile, Cole Palmer was denied a penalty after being wiped out by Luke O’Nien.

Gillett did not award a foul in real time, while VAR ruled the contact occurred outside the penalty area. Chelsea supporters are convinced the officials got it wrong, but what do former professionals Chris Sutton and Gary Bennett think?

TalkingPoints

Chelsea lose to Sunderland AGAIN! Who do you blame for the defeat? 🤔

Chris Sutton and Gary Bennett disagree over Cole Palmer penalty shout

Former Chelsea striker Chris Sutton was surprised that Jarred Gillett failed to award a foul for the challenge on Cole Palmer, but agreed with VAR’s decision not to give a penalty. He believes Luke O’Nien made contact with the 24-year-old outside the penalty area.

“The truth is Chelsea have been second best – even though they should be hard done by on the Cole Palmer decision,” Sutton said on commentary for Sky Sports. “It’s not a penalty, as I think the initial contact is outside the box, but it is a foul. Jarred Gillett and VAR decided to play on.”

However, Sunderland legend Gary Bennett appeared to disagree, suggesting O’Nien was fortunate not to concede a penalty. He warned the Black Cats that the challenge could have given Chelsea the chance to take a 1-0 lead.

“Tell you what, Luke O’Nien is lucky,” Bennett told BBC Sport. “Sunderland have to take that on board. They need to be wary of that. It’s a warning.”

Chelsea were below their best for much of the match, but the two penalty incidents proved decisive talking points. The Blues will feel aggrieved that neither decision went their way, particularly given how differently the officials judged the challenges on Palmer and Brobbey.

You may like

Chelsea ratings: Morgan Rogers struggles leading the line as Pep Chavarria a bright spark in othe...

The Sun 1 hour ago

Chris Sutton cannot hide his Rangers hatred after what he said live on Sky Sports

rangersnews.uk 20 hours ago

Chelsea player ratings vs Sunderland as 4/10 attacker disappoints alongside Levi Colwill

thechelseachronicle.com 1 hour ago

Alonso urges Cole Palmer ‘to learn’ from red card in Chelsea’s defeat to Spurs

The Guardian 2 weeks ago

Thomas Tuchel got it right: Chelsea's Cole Palmer shouldn't be in the England squad

3addedminutes.com 1 day ago

Sunderland 1-0 Chelsea: Blues pay the penalty as Enzo Le Fee lifts Black Cats off foot of Premier...

aol.co.uk 1 hour ago

England Under-15s walk off pitch against Ireland in World Cup after racism allegation

The Guardian 1 week ago

Chelsea fans furious after two penalty calls go against Blues in first half

talkchelsea.net 2 hours ago