Which Arsenal team is the fairest reflection of Arsene Wenger’s 22 years in charge of the club?

The Invincibles seem the obvious answer, but it paints too rosy a picture for a manager who subsequently oversaw a decade of angst and frustration. Likewise, focusing too much on those latter years does a disservice to a man who is credited with revolutionising English football.

The gap between going an entire season unbeaten and those barren years without a trophy is so small, to meet in the middle brings us to one season: 2004-05.

We want to talk in particular about the afternoon of November 28, 2004, and Arsenal’s trip to Anfield.

The game is notable for featuring not one but two of the Premier League’s greatest forgotten goals.

First, Xabi Alonso – already an underrated great goalscorer – put Liverpool ahead in a role reversal with Steven Gerrard, who played a cute inside pass for the Spaniard to run on to and rifle into the top corner from the edge of the box.

Wenger was able to field nine of the Invincibles’ first-choice XI that day – Cesc Fabregas replaced Gilberto Silva in midfield and Jose Antonio Reyes, rather than Dennis Bergkamp, partnered Thierry Henry in attack – but the Gunners were largely outplayed by Liverpool in the opening hour.

Yet something just suddenly clicked, as it so often did with those players.

Patrick Vieira drove forward from midfield and played the ball into Henry. While any defence would rather have Henry with his back to goal rather than facing it, this part of his game was so often overlooked.

Pinning Steve Finnan, Henry laid the ball off to Robert Pires while, crucially, Vieira continued his run into the box.

Ah, Pires – a footballer cut from silk. Lovely, lovely Le Bob. After the blur of Vieira passed his eye line, Pires didn’t even look up before playing a perfectly weighted one-touch pass into the path of his fellow Frenchman.

Vieira, so often cast as the enforcer of Wenger’s fleet-footed urchins, impudently dinked the ball over Chris Kirkland. Meanwhile, Jamie Carragher was busy trying to put his feet back on the right way around.

Before the ball had even crossed the line, Vieira turned to celebrate with the away end next to the goal. Bliss.

Patrick Vieira, that is sublime! 🍟#GoalOfTheDay pic.twitter.com/t24uLlAbj6

— Premier League (@premierleague) March 24, 2020

Suddenly, it didn’t matter that Liverpool had dominated the opening hour of football. But unlike the previous season, the players who had just conjured such a beautiful piece of football out of thin air failed to hold on to a result.

In stoppage time, lacking Gilberto to patrol in front of the back four, the ball broke loose in front of Arsenal’s penalty area. Neil Mellor, searching for his first Premier League goal, was the quickest to react and half-volleyed a clinical strike into the bottom corner.

It's stoppage time, it's 1-1 at Anfield and the Liverpool academy graduate does THIS 🚀

Who remembers this Neil Mellor strike against Arsenal?! 🤩pic.twitter.com/sGAt35MTg7

— GOAL (@goal) November 28, 2019

Perhaps Vieira’s goal, that defeat, and this season is the truest snapshot of Arsenal under Wenger.

The Invincibles’ unbeaten streak had already come to an end a month earlier at the hands of Manchester United and Mike Riley.

Defeat at Anfield made it just one victory in nine matches in all competitions. Their unprecedented dominance of the previous campaign had already been undermined by obvious vulnerabilities.

But the season didn’t end there. They dusted themselves off, won 16 of their remaining 23 Premier League fixtures to finish ahead of Manchester United but behind the new-monied, newly-Mourinhoed Chelsea, and showed the mental resolve to come out on top in a turgid FA Cup final against their old adversaries in Fergie’s side – what proved to be Arsenal’s final honour for almost a decade.

The man who had the nerve to score the winning penalty in the FA Cup was the same man who calmly finished such a beautiful move against Liverpool.

Maybe it’s only fitting if peak-Wenger, peak-Arsenal and peak-Vieira are all one and the same.